By Alexina Cather, MPH and Charles Platkin, PhD, JD, MPH
Since the 1980’s there have been strict limits on the number of food carts and trucks allowed to vend on New York City streets. The cap on the number of permits has resulted in a thriving black market for vending permits, allowing incumbent permit holders, many of whom are no longer street vendors, to illegally rent permits for tens of thousands of dollars.
On October 2016, the New York City Council Committee on Consumer Affairs convened hearings on the proposed Street Vending Modernization Act to amend the New York City charter and administrative code of the City of New York to:
- Double the number of food vendor permits over seven years with five percent of new permits being set aside for veterans and the disabled
- Create a new dedicated vendor law enforcement unit to make sure vending rules and regulations are followed and applied fairly and consistently
- Focus initial enforcement efforts on congested areas and around supermarkets
- Improve compliance by installing street signs on blocks without legal vending, creating an app with a satellite view of legal vending spots, and requiring vendor training
- Establish a street vendor advisory panel to monitor enforcement and new permit rollouts and to examine and make recommendations for streamlining vendor laws and rules
- Establish a pilot program to examine methods of maintaining order in congested areas and create model vending zones
- Establish a pilot program to test the use of public school and other underutilized kitchens for use by food vendors
- Refine various outdated rules governing food vending
There is a strong rationale for the proposed bill, which will increase food vendor permits, for the evident benefits of job creation among immigrants and other entrepreneurs, freedom of enterprise, and improving the equity dialogue; however, any legislation regulating the selling of food in an urban center like New York City requires strict consideration of its health impact, and presents an opportunity not only to increase new micro-businesses, but also to promote health. The proposed bill offers a unique opportunity to include amendments, which could go further toward protecting the health of New Yorkers and its millions of annual visitors, to include certain health provisions that impact nutrition and food safety.
Great strides have been made in improving public health across New York City in recent years, notably reducing the number of both obese and severely obese public school children. However, the statistics are still grim, and New York remains in the midst of an epidemic of diet-related diseases that are disproportionately impacting racial/ethnic minorities and those with lower incomes:
- More than half of adult New Yorkers are overweight (34 percent) or obese (25 percent), and obesity is associated with poorer mental health outcomes, reduced quality of life and some of the leading causes of death in this country: diabetes, heart disease, stroke and certain cancers.
- More than one in ten New Yorkers are living with diabetes, putting them at increased risk of heart attack, stroke, blindness, kidney failure, nerve damage and amputations.
- More than one in three adults lives with cardiovascular disease. Heart disease and stroke are among the leading causes of death in New York City.
- Only 10 percent of New Yorkers are consuming the recommended daily servings of fruits and vegetables.
While many laudable initiatives have significantly improved the city’s food landscape across the five boroughs (e.g., Green Carts, Shop Healthy, Farmers Markets/Health Bucks, and FRESH), there is more that can be done and street vendors can play a critical role in increasing access – to either healthy or unhealthy foods. Studies show the negative impact of street vendors selling unhealthy products:
- A 2014 study of mobile food vendors in the Bronx showed that unhealthy food vendors outnumbered healthy ones, and the former can negatively impact the overall healthfulness of a neighborhood’s food environment – with researchers adding the important caveat that “it need not.”
- Research on urban food vending indicates that mobile food vendors contribute to after-school snacking among children, a consideration that should be given due concern, considering the number of our city’s public school children who walk by vendors on their way to/from school or transit to school.
To address nutritional concerns, adding an incentive for vendors who display calorie and/or nutritional information for the products they are selling (as well as ingredients lists, upon request), who sell only fruits and vegetables, and/or who locate their carts in areas designated as in need of additional healthy food outlets will encourage increased transparency around healthy food consumption. These recommendations are aligned with previous city regulations (i.e., menu labeling in chain restaurants and Green Carts requirements), and would further the city’s efforts to promote healthy eating, address disparities in access to nutritious food and improve the overall food environment.
Global health and wellness sales are expected to hit a high of $1 trillion in the United States in the coming year. Research has shown that customers increasingly want and seek healthy options, and are willing to pay more for them (if their income allows). Stands that sold healthier items fared just as well economically as those vending unhealthy products. Corner stores that sold produce made a higher profit from fruits and vegetables than from energy-dense snacks. Restaurant chains that increased their lower-calorie food and beverage offerings had increased sales and customer traffic. In NYC, one can point to the success of restaurants offering healthy food and beverages such as Dig Inn, Roast Kitchen, The Butcher’s Daughter, Fresh & Co., Chop’t, Sweetgreen, Liquiteria and Hu.
While the research on calorie menu labeling and/or nutrient labeling has shown mixed results,,,, studies that demonstrate a positive impact have also provided anecdotal evidence that show that labeling creates conversation and awareness around healthy food choice and consumption– and still has significant value as a base to improve healthy food policy.
The city has taken steps to improve food safety for those who eat out, including the 2010 legislation that introduced restaurant letter grading, which informs consumers at point-of-entry of every establishment’s sanitary status. While NYC’s mobile food vendors are required to take the Food Protection Course for Mobile Vendors, food safety in mobile vending (with inherent challenges such as lack of access to running water) remains a grave concern.
- A study of NYC food vendors published in Public Health Reports (the official journal of the U.S. Public Health Service and the U.S. Surgeon General) documented risks to public health, including unsanitary food handling, food contamination, and meat storage at potentially improper temperatures.
- A 2015 study of Manhattan food vendors found that the majority (57 percent) of vendors did not change gloves after handling money, a requirement of the NYC Health Code to prevent foodborne illnesses.
To address food safety considerations, vendors should undergo supplementary training that includes education covering the most common violations that put the public at risk for foodborne illness. Food vendors are currently obligated to take a food safety course, however, research shows that street food vendors need additional specialized food safety training, including information on how they can avoid expensive violations. Opening up more than 600 new permits is a unique opportunity to continue the narrative and discussion regarding a higher level of training for new food vendors.
Proposing these amendments in the form of an incentive to vendors, to encourage adoption – rather than as yet another requirement subject to a fine if not met (as a study shows that the majority of street vendor fines go unpaid and the goal is not to place undue burden on vendors) could yield positive results and improve the nutritional quality of food served by street vendors throughout New York City.
 Berger M, Konty K, Day S, Silver LD, Nonas C, Kerker BD, et al. Obesity in K–8 students — New York City, 2006–07 to 2010–11 school years. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2011;60(49):1673–1678.
 Day SE, Konty KJ, Leventer-Roberts M, Nonas C, Harris TG. Severe obesity among children in New York City public elementary and middle schools, school years 2006-07 through 2010-11. Prev Chron Dis. 2014; Jul 10;11:E118. doi: 10.5888/pcd11.130439.
 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. Epiquery: NYC Interactive Health Data System – Community Health Survey 2014. Accessed October 27, 2016. https://nyc.gov/health/epiquery.
 U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Adult Obesity Causes and Consequences. https://www.cdc.gov/obesity/adult/causes.html. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 Gupta L, Olson C. Diabetes in New York City. New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene: Epi Data Brief 25; April 2013.
 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. Heart Disease. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/health/health-topics/heart-disease.page. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. Epiquery: NYC Interactive Health Data System – Mortality Module. https://a816-healthpsi.nyc.gov/epiquery/sasresults.jsp. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 Lucan SC, Maroko AR, Bumol J, et al. Mobile food vendors in urban neighborhoods—implications for diet and diet-related health by weather and season. Health Place. 2014;27:171-175.
 Tester JM, Yen IH, Laraia B. Mobile food vending and the after-school food environment. Am J Prev Med. 2010;38;70-73.
 Hudson E. Health and wellness: the trillion dollar industry in 2017: key research highlights. Euromonitor International. November 29, 2012. https://blog.euromonitor.com/2012/11/health-and-wellness-the-trillion-dollar-industry-in-2017-key-research-highlights.html. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 Nielsen. We are what we eat: healthy eating trends around the world. January 2015. https://www.nielsen.com/content/dam/nielsenglobal/eu/nielseninsights/pdfs/Nielsen%20Global%20Health%20and%20Wellness%20Report%20-%20January%202015.pdf. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 Gagliardi N. Consumers want healthy foods—and will pay more for them. Forbes.com. February 18, 2015. https://www.forbes.com/sites/nancygagliardi/2015/02/18/consumers-want-healthy-foods-and-will-pay-more-for-them/#78282948144f. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 Laroche HH, Ford C, Hansen K, et al. Concession stand makeovers: a pilot study of offering healthy foods at high school concession stands. J Public Health (Oxf). 2015 Mar;37(1):116-24. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdu015.
 Dunaway LF, Mundorf AR, Rose D. Fresh fruit and vegetable profitability: insights from a corner store intervention in New Orleans, Louisiana. J Hunger Env Nutr. 2016;11, https://dx.doi.org/10.1080/19320248.2016.1227746.
 Hudson Institute. Lower calorie foods: it’s just good business. Obesity Solutions Initiative. February 2013. https://www.rwjf.org/content/dam/farm/reports/reports/2013/rwjf404136. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 Vadiveloo MK, Dixon LB, Elbel B. Consumer purchasing patterns in response to calorie labeling legislation in New York City. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2011;8:51. doi: 10.1186/1479-5868-8-51.
 Elbel B, Kersh R, Brescoll VL, Dixon LB. Calorie labeling and food choices: a first look at the effects on low-income people in New York City. Health Aff (Millwood). 2009 Nov-Dec;28(6):w1110-21. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.28.6.w1110. Epub 2009 Oct 6.
 Dumanovsky T1, Huang CY, Bassett MT, Silver LD. Consumer awareness of fast-food calorie information in New York City after implementation of a menu labeling regulation. Am J Public Health. 2010;100:2520-2525. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2010.191908. Epub 2010 Oct 21.
 Dumanovsky T, Huang CY, Nonas CA, Matte TD, Bassett MT, Silver LD. Changes in energy content of lunchtime purchases from fast food restaurants after introduction of calorie labelling: cross sectional customer surveys. BMJ. 2011;343:d4464. doi: 10.1136/bmj.d4464.
 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. Mobile & Temporary Food Vendors. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/business/food-operators/mobile-and-temporary-food-vendors.page. Accessed October 27, 2016.
 Burt MB, Volel C, Finkel M. Safety of vendor-prepared foods: evaluation of 10 processing mobile food vendors in Manhattan. Public Health Rep. 2003 Sep-Oct;118(5):470-476.
 Basch CH, Guerra LA, MacDonald Z, Marte M, Basch CE. Glove changing habits in mobile food vendors in New York City. J Community Health. 2015;40: 699. doi:10.1007/s10900-014-9987-7.
 Carroll KA, Basinsky S, Morales A. Fining the hand that feeds you: situational and violation-specific factors influencing New York street vendor default in payment. Cityscape: J Pol Devp Res. 2016;18;89-107.
 Wanskin B, Love K. Slim by design: Menu strategies for promoting high-margin, healthy foods. Int J Hospital Manage. 2014;42:137-143.
 Foster GD, Karpyn A, Wojtanowski AC. Placement and promotion strategies to increase sales of healthier products in supermarkets in low-income, ethnically diverse neighborhoods: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr. 2014;99:1359-1368.
 Wansink B. Change their choice! Changing behavior using the CAN approach and activism research. Psych Marketing. 2015;32;486-500.
 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. Adopt a Shop. https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/pan/adopt-a-shop-guide.pdf. Accessed October 27, 2016.